CNN has a fascinating article on what’s at stake in Iowa for the Democratic candidates; I thought I would wade in on the issue before the results tonight.
Barack Obama
Beat Clinton and you’re the president. That’s it. You don’t have to come in first, everyone else can spank you but so long as you beat Clinton you’ll be president. The slightest amount of momentum is all you need to bury this thing, show you can beat Hillary and no one can stop you…unless racism comes back. Barack recently said he expects a high turnout in Iowa because he’s seen lots of people at speeches in really bad weather so he thinks the Iowa electorate is engaged - no other candidate has made similar remarks. I believe this is because more people are turning out for Obama than the others. Why? They want to meet the next president.
Dennis Kucinich
He’s encouraged Iowa voters to make Obama their second choice. This means he knows he’ll lose in the first round, not expecting to make the 15% threshold and wants to support Obama in the second round. This kind of maneuvering makes for good VP material if you ask me. I’d love to see an Obama/Kucinich ticket; I think it’s the best possible outcome ideologically once we accept Obama/McCain will never happen.
John Edwards
Come in the top 3 and you’re still in the race - don’t make the top three and it’s time to decide if you want to support Obama or Clinton and make a grab for the VP spot again. As much as I’d love to see Kucinich as a running mate Edwards is the guy that would mitigate any risk one might feel voting for Obama or Clinton. He’s safe but not exciting – excellent VP material. If Obama/Kucinich is best ideologically then Obama/Edwards is best strategically.
Hillary Clinton
If Obama beats you, he’s the next president - if you beat him narrowly, it’s still a race. It you beat him by a wide margin you can probably take Edwards down and get the nomination. Then you’ll lose to McCain or someone when the actual election comes around.
Bill Richardson
Come in the top 4 Bill. It’s sad to see the low expectations people have for you, show them you’re still relevant by making the top 4 and keep fighting. You never know, you could be VP or be a serious contender next cycle.
Joe Biden
As the CNN fellow says double digits will keep him going and I think having him in the conversation improves it. He won’t crack the top 3 though, mark my words. He and Richardson will fight for 4th since Kucinich is throwing his weight behind Obama second round.
Mike Gravel
Sadly I must agree with the CNN boys, he won’t survive this caucus with anything more than Joe-mentum level support. Will he face facts and drop out so we can focus on the big boys? Hopefully as I’d hate to see more of that Joe-mentum defiance of reality.
Chris Dodd
Accept facts, President Dodd will never happen. Throw any support you may have behind Obama now and save yourself the embarrassment of a single-digit showing.
Okay, fine, I’ll do it. Predictions… (Latest poll percentage in parenthesis)
#1 - Barack Obama (30%)
The voters in Iowa will realize he’s less vulnerable to Republican attack. Hillary can be attacked on relevant grounds; all they can do to Obama is make fun of his name. They could attack his experience but a general disdain for Washington insiders is part of the ‘conventional wisdom’ that comes part and parcel with the fear-mongering and other mainstays of the Republican Party during an election cycle. Also, you wave a picture of Hillary at a GOP fundraiser and the cash comes pouring in, do the same with Obama and you have to accept a contribution from the KKK. The second round will see his numbers increase with Kucinich and other supporters moving over when their guys don’t break 15% in the first round.
#2 - Hillary Clinton (40%)
Much as it pains me to admit, she’s the game to beat. But her inconsistencies, background, and support for the Iraq war in her voting record will end up costing her. The Republicans would like her to win the nomination as they’ll have a field day with attack ads, the same cannot be said for any other candidate. I don’t think her numbers will go up in the second round; you’re either with her or you’re not, she’s nobody’s second choice.
#3 - John Edwards (15%)
Just look at the polls, the top 3 is already decided it’s just a matter of who gets which spot. We’ll probably see an increase in his numbers in the second round.
#4 - Joe Biden (4%)
Kucinich will drop out in the first round; Biden looks more presidential than the other remaining candidates.
#5 - Bill Richardson (4%)
Will be eliminated first round. He may get double digits but he won’t break 15% first round. He’ll find just enough support to keep going until he can try and cash in on the Hispanic vote in Nevada, but by then they’ll be mostly supporting Obama preferring to vote strategically for someone who can win rather than voting along purely racial lines.
#6 - Dennis Kucinich (2%)
Will be eliminated first round. Dennis knows he won’t reach 15% and has planned accordingly.
#7 - Mike Gravel (<1%)
Will be eliminated first round. Won’t break double digits first round but will pull ahead of Dodd when things get serious.
#8 - Chris Dodd (2%)
Will be eliminated first round. But will he get the message?
Predicted Fallout
Gravel and Dodd will call it a day, everyone else will move along to New Hampshire. Richardson will drop out after failing to deliver high enough numbers in Nevada on the 19th. Biden will drop out after the South Carolina primary and Kucinich will either stay with it to end without becoming a serious threat to the top three or bow out at some point before Super Tuesday and throw all his weight behind Obama. Obama will win the nomination with Edwards as a running mate as things got too heated with Hillary for quick reconciliation. All the Republicans would have to do is make a commercial with creative editing of them sparring and you destroy any credibility of a united Democratic front. But Obama/Edwards will crush the GOP in November and the world will breath a profound sigh of relief.
To summarize and further beat the dead horse what this all comes down to is Clinton versus Obama. If Obama wins the Democrats have this thing in the bag, if Clinton wins we’ve got a long hard fight ahead of us.
On the other side I see Paul and Hunter dropping out after abysmal showings, Giuliani losing some ground but still remaining relevant; Huckabee, Romney, and McCain all gain ground. Thompson’s impossible to predict at this time. If the Republicans knew what they were doing they’d send McCain to beat the democrats at their own game but thus far it seems they either haven’t figured that out or care about other things more.
Depending on who gets the nominations I may just host a party election night that may or may not include a suspension of the Swear Jar. If it’s interesting like Obama/Edwards versus McCain/Anyone then let’s do it but if it’s boring like Edwards/Biden versus Huckabee/Romney I’d probably fall asleep mid-results and that wouldn’t make for a good party.
Update: There are conflicting reports that Bill Richardson’s camp is lending it’s support to Obama in areas in which they don’t reach the 15% threshold. With Kucinich already having stated this publicly estimates say at least half of the second tier votes would be earmarked for Obama in the second round. As well conflicting polls contradict the numbers mentioned earlier, some polls have Obama above Hillary and Edwards’ gap to Hillary much closer, perhaps as close as within 2%. This is going to be interesting.
Update: This just in, now it seems rumours are circulating that Biden’s camp is backing Obama as a second choice. Although it’s suspect because the reports claim this deal was made to swing Obama overflow to Biden to defeat Richardson which contradict prior reports regarding Richardson. I suppose it could be possible that both are true but at different locations. Either way I take these reports as good signs. It’s like I said, Hillary’s no one’s second choice.
Update: Meanwhile on the other side Republicans are tearing themselves apart with dirty in-fighting. It’s like Christmas for us left-leaners. It’s not enough that Huckabee and Romney were launching attack ads at each other recently or that McCain recently expressed annoyance at Ron Paul as a spoiler in Iowa without a national campaign (and why I was barely aware of his existence) but they’ve now taken it up a notch. Or perhaps more accurately, down a level.
The Huckabee camp is claiming that Romney is sabotaging them by sending false addresses for precinct locations to known Huckabee supporters. The Romney camp fired back with the same accusation. A little, and I do mean little, investigating turned up that an e-mail from GOP HQ contained some errors that lead to all of this. The tiniest glitch and they tear each other apart and the first primary hasn’t even begun! Meanwhile the Democrats are too busy supporting each other. Headlines I’ve seen include things like “Democrats Predict Record Turnout, Republicans Predict Reasonable Turnout“.
It looks like the midterms were just an appetizer for the Bush backlash. The Republican party is falling apart and the strongest Democratic contender is raising an army.