NDP Reply Take 2
September 30, 2006What follows is what I think is an actual reply to my message. While it makes some good points it still seems to distill down to ‘things aren’t working so let’s give up’…
Thank you for your comments on Canada’s military mission in Afghanistan.
I welcome the opportunity to explain further the federal NDP’s position
on Canada’s role in Afghanistan.http://www.ndp.ca/page/3620)http://www.senliscouncil.net/modules/publications/014_publication)http://tinyurl.com/g372b);
(http://www.ndp.ca/page/4308)http://www.ndp.ca/page/4330)http://www.ndp.ca or
subscribe to our e-mail bulletin, e-NDP, at subscribe@ndp.ca.
We believe that Canadians deserve a full explanation about why we’ve
committed to our largest military deployment in 50 years. However,
Harper’s Conservatives have failed time and again to answer the tough
questions that current Minister of Defence O’Connor himself asked the
previous Liberal government. (
The NDP fully supports sending our brave men and women of the armed
forces on missions that have clear goals and a specific plan on what our
soldiers need to do to achieve victory. The truth is that the mission in
Afghanistan has neither. The bottom line is that the NDP supports our
troops but we want to make sure that this mission is worthy of their
dedication and sacrifice.
Our policy calls on Prime Minister Harper to begin “the safe and
immediate withdrawal of Canadian troops from Afghanistan” and “support
the continuation of development assistance to Afghanistan and democratic
peace building.”
Since 2001, military efforts in Afghanistan have failed to bring peace,
reduce poverty, stop heroin production, or help reconstruct Afghanistan.
NATO was supposed to secure some areas of the country, where
institutions could be strengthened and development projects executed,
and therefore help the Afghan government deliver stability to its
citizens. The sad truth is that both U.S. and NATO military efforts have
failed to deliver peace and prosperity to the most vulnerable of
Afghans: women and children.
(
1,600 Afghans have died in the last four months alone. We believe that
democracy building is what the Afghan people want, not more violence and
instability.
Malalai Joya, a female parliamentarian in the Afghan National Assembly,
told the 2006 NDP Convention that: “The situation in Afghanistan and
conditions of its ill-fated women will never change positively, as long
as the warlords are not disarmed and both the pro-US and anti-US
terrorists are removed from the political scene of Afghanistan.”
Earlier this week, Captain Leo Docherty, a former aide-de-camp to the
commander of British forces in Helmand Province, said the NATO-led
mission had been “grotesquely clumsy” and “sucked [NATO] into a problem
unsolvable by military means.” (
More and more voices have called for a change in tactics, but Prime
Minister Harper chooses to ignore those “on the ground”.
(
Our troops deserve to know what we are asking of them, families deserve
to know what their sons and daughters will be called upon to sacrifice.
The NDP resolution on Afghanistan reflects our respect for our troops in
that Canada should not commit our soldiers without the certainty that
their valiant efforts are part of a carefully constructed and balanced
mission that holds real prospects of making the world a safer place.
Again, I appreciate the time you have taken to register your views.
Sincerely,
Jack Layton, MP (Toronto-Danforth)
Leader, New Democratic Party of Canada
To catch up on recent news and issues, please visit
Posted by cowmanx